Key takeaways: Return fraud only affects a minority of returns, but it takes many forms: systematic returns after use, empty parcels, fraudulent exchanges. Certain behavioral signals help you spot risky profiles before they cost you too much.
A customer's abnormally high return rate
A customer who returns a share of their orders well above your store's average deserves your attention. Typical return rates vary a lot from one sector to another: compare each customer with your own average. When they exceed it by a wide margin, for example double, you are looking at unusual behavior.
This signal alone proves nothing: some customers simply struggle to find their size, or order several variants to choose from. But combined with other indicators, it becomes relevant. Look in particular at whether these returns always come at the end of the allowed period, or whether the stated reasons change from one order to the next.
Returns that always land just before the deadline
You notice that a customer always returns items 13 or 14 days after delivery, while your policy allows 14 days? That's a classic sign of use followed by a return. The product was probably used for a specific occasion: a dress for a wedding, a tool for a one-off job, a camera for a weekend.
This practice, sometimes called "wardrobing" in fashion, is a common form of return fraud. Items often come back with subtle signs of use: unusual creases, faint smells, tags clumsily sewn back on. A return that always lands at the end of the period is your first clue.
The parcel returned empty or with another product
This is the most direct fraud: you receive an empty parcel, or one containing a different item (often a worthless product or an old model). The customer claims to have sent back the right item and blames your logistics.
This kind of fraud is still uncommon. It exploits the fact that many online sellers refund before checking the contents, to keep things smooth. Without systematic weighing of returned parcels or filmed unboxing, you are exposed. Keep track of customers who report this kind of problem repeatedly: "the parcel got lost", "you claim you received nothing".
Multiple orders, only one item kept
A customer orders the same item in three sizes or four colors, keeps one and returns the rest. In itself, this is a common and legitimate practice, and many online sellers even encourage it to reduce friction at checkout.
The warning sign appears when this behavior becomes systematic, on every order, with large volumes. Some customers order many items every week, keep only one or two, and start again endlessly. You become their free fitting room, with logistics costs that explode. These profiles are sometimes resellers testing products before offering them elsewhere.
A delivery address that keeps changing
A customer who uses a different delivery address for every order, while keeping the same billing address, can signal several things. Often, it simply means deliveries to an office, to relatives, or to different pickup points.
But this signal becomes relevant when it comes with a high return rate and frequent complaints. Some fraudsters use this technique to blur the trail of their actions or to resell products to third parties. Others use it to claim a welcome offer several times or to get around a block.
Inconsistent or vague return reasons
When a customer states "doesn't meet my expectations" on every return, without ever giving details, it often signals a return after use. Honest customers who run into a real problem are usually more specific: "size too small", "color different from the photo", "stitching defect".
Conversely, reasons that change radically from one return to the next for the same customer can also raise a flag. One day "too big", the next "too small", then "defective", then "never ordered": this inconsistency suggests the customer adapts their story to maximize their chances of a refund.
Aggressive or threatening complaints
Some fraudsters rely on pressure. They immediately threaten a negative review, a complaint or exposure on social media if you don't refund instantly, without any check.
This behavior aims to bypass your normal processes. An unhappy customer acting in good faith can be firm, but usually accepts that their request will be reviewed. The fraudster refuses any delay or check, because they know their case won't hold up to scrutiny. A mismatch between the tone and the stakes (threatening to sue over €30) is a signal in itself.
A recently created account with a large first order
A new customer who immediately places a large order (several hundred euros) often carries a higher risk. Many customers start by testing a site with a small order.
Weigh this signal against your sector: in luxury or high-tech, large first orders are normal. But in fashion or home decor, a big basket for a first purchase deserves special attention, especially if the customer asks for a partial or full return a few days later.
What to do about these signals
None of these signals is proof on its own. A customer can behave unusually for legitimate reasons. The point is to combine several indicators to identify the truly risky profiles.
In practice, you can set up an internal score: each signal adds points and, above a threshold, the account goes to manual review. For these customers, you can ask for photos before the return, inspect every parcel, or make the refund conditional on actually receiving the product in good condition.
Some online sellers also choose to charge return shipping to risky profiles, or to limit the number of returns allowed per period. Check that these measures are stated in your policy and compatible with the right of withdrawal. The goal isn't to stop all returns, but to make fraud less profitable than honest buying.
This article first appeared on the Hey’ Return blog, the returns management tool of the Heylio suite. Discover Hey’ Return