← Back to Blog

Refurbish or not: deciding item by item without spending all day on it

Not every return deserves to be refurbished. A simple decision grid, based on the item's value and the real cost of the work, rather than on the receiving clerk's gut feeling.

Heylio Team August 18, 2026 3 min read

Key takeaways: Whether to refurbish depends on three variables: the item's residual value, the cost of the work and the likelihood of resale. A grid applied at receiving, with written thresholds, beats case-by-case judgment calls. It is faster and more consistent.

A decision made constantly, never written down

At receiving, someone decides whether an item goes back on sale, to secondhand, into a bundle lot, or on hold. The decision takes a few seconds, often on instinct, and added up it weighs heavily on the value you recover.

It deserves a written grid. Not to remove judgment: the receiving clerk's eye beats a rule in many cases. But so that common cases are handled the same way from one person to the next and from one day to the next.

The three variables that decide

Residual value. Not the original selling price: what the item is worth today, in its condition, on the channel where it can be sold again. A last-season garment returned in February is no longer worth its price tag.

The cost of the work. Inspection, cleaning, ironing, new packaging, new photos if the channel requires them, restocking. This cost is often fairly stable within a product family, so you can estimate it once rather than for every item.

The likelihood of resale. A popular item will sell again; an item you already have forty units of in stock will take up a shelf for months. The question isn't "can it be sold" but "can it be sold before it has cost more than it's worth".

A written threshold beats a judgment call

The simplest and most workable rule is a value threshold.

Below a certain amount, a thorough inspection costs more than it can save: the item goes straight to the secondary channel, without a detailed check. Above it, the item justifies spending time on it.

You can calculate this threshold: it is the average cost of a full inspection in your organization, labor included. It is often higher than people think, and teams sometimes carefully inspect items whose inspection costs more than the value it protects.

The observed condition, in a few categories

A useful grid has four or five conditions, not fifteen. Too many categories slow the decision down and lead to inconsistent sorting between operators.

A breakdown that works well in practice: grade A (resellable as is), grade B (resellable with a note, small markdown), to refurbish (one identified operation is enough), to check (in doubt, set aside for a second look), factory defect (goes back to the supplier, not to secondhand).

Each of these conditions must match a physical destination and an action, otherwise it serves no purpose.

Destruction is no longer a default option

Regulations have narrowed the possibility of disposing of unsold goods in good condition. Beyond the legal obligation, the economics point the same way: destroying a resellable item means paying twice, first the cost of the product, then the cost of disposing of it.

That means having secondary channels truly open before you need them: a "secondhand" section on your own site, a clearance partner, a donation channel. A channel you open in a hurry, with a pile of unsold stock already built up, is a channel you negotiate badly.

Measuring what the grid recovers

A grid without measurement drifts within a few months. Two indicators are enough to keep it on track: the share of returns put back on sale and the average value recovered per return.

The first tells you whether the sorting works. The second tells you whether it pays. A high resale rate, achieved by refurbishing items with no value, is not an achievement: it's a hidden cost.

Look at them together every month: they are enough to adjust the threshold without turning it into a project.

This article first appeared on the Hey’ Return blog, the returns management tool of the Heylio suite. Discover Hey’ Return

Automate your customer support with AI

Get started