Key takeaways: Free returns improve conversion and increase return volume. The balance depends on unit margin, the real logistics cost and the category's return rate. The calculation is simple to set up, and the answer varies widely from one catalog to another.
A question averages can't answer
You read everywhere that free returns have become standard, and elsewhere that they wreck margins. Both claims are true, for different catalogs.
The calculation is not complicated. It takes four figures you already have, and it gives an answer specific to your situation.
The four figures
Unit gross margin on an average item, in euros rather than as a percentage.
The full cost of a return: return shipping, receiving, inspection, restocking, plus any markdown if the item doesn't go back on sale at full price. This is the figure most often underestimated, because people only count shipping.
Your current return rate, on the scope in question.
The expected effect on conversion. It is the only figure you have to estimate, and the only honest way to get it is to test.
Setting up the equation
Making returns free has two opposite effects.
On the plus side: more orders. The gain is the number of extra orders multiplied by the unit margin.
On the minus side: more returns, and each return now also costs you its shipping. The loss is twofold: the extra returns on existing volume, and the returns generated by the new orders.
Free returns win when the conversion gain, valued in margin, exceeds the extra cost of the additional returns. Nothing more.
Why unit margin decides almost everything
Take an example, with six euros of return shipping. An item with eighty euros of margin absorbs it easily, even if it is returned often. An item with seven euros of margin does not: each return wipes out almost the entire margin of a sale, not to mention the sale itself, which is lost.
That is why the same decision is obvious one way for high-end furniture and the other way for low-priced accessories, and why applying a single rule to a mixed catalog is almost always a mistake.
The middle-ground options are underused
Between "free for everyone" and "paid for everyone", several positions hold up well.
Free above a cart threshold. Aligns the cost with the available margin and naturally pushes the average order value up.
Free for exchanges, paid for refunds. Steers toward the option that preserves revenue, without ever blocking the refund, which remains a right.
Free depending on the reason. A defective product or a picking error should never be charged to the customer: it is your mistake. A change of mind can be. This distinction is well understood and rarely disputed.
Free by category. Easy to explain if the split is clear, confusing if it needs a table.
What is actually prohibited
A legal point not to miss: return costs can be left to the consumer, but only if they were informed before ordering. A notice tucked into the terms and conditions after checkout does not meet that condition, and the costs then fall on you.
And when the customer exercises their right of withdrawal, the outbound delivery costs must in principle be refunded to them, whether the return is free or not. Check the rule in force and its limits (with the relevant consumer authority or your legal advisor) before writing your policy.
Test rather than decide
The effect on conversion is the only uncertain term in the equation, and it is the one where industry averages transfer least.
A test on one category, over several weeks, gives a solid answer. Two precautions: measure the returns from the test period on the cohort concerned, not on the calendar month, and wait until the return window has closed before drawing conclusions. Many tests are read too early, when conversion has already moved and the returns have not come in yet. They then conclude in favor of free returns, and are often wrong.
This article first appeared on the Hey’ Return blog, the returns management tool of the Heylio suite. Discover Hey’ Return