Key takeaways: The loi AGEC (France's anti-waste and circular economy law) bans the destruction of most unsold non-food goods, including products your customers send back. You must favor reuse, repair, donation or recycling, and document your practices.
The destruction ban also covers customer returns
Yes, the products your customers return fall within the scope of the AGEC law. Since this ban took effect, you can no longer destroy new unsold non-food goods, whether they are dormant stock or e-commerce returns. The law makes no distinction: a product returned, within the withdrawal period or after it, remains an unsold item covered by the ban. Application dates vary by product: check the one that applies to your category.
The ban covers many families of non-food products: textiles, footwear, electrical and electronic equipment, furniture, books, hygiene products, among others. Only a few very specific cases are exempt, notably for proven health reasons. Check the exact scope for your products with your eco-organization (the industry body that handles end-of-life obligations for your sector) or an advisor.
What to do with your returns in practice
Set up a processing hierarchy. First, put products in good condition back on sale. It's the most obvious solution, but it requires careful sorting as soon as the return arrives.
Next, for damaged or unboxed products you can't resell at full price, several options are open to you:
- Refurbishing: cleaning, restoring, reselling secondhand or through an outlet
- Donation: to charities, work-integration organizations or social aid groups
- Recycling: dismantling and material recovery through approved channels
- Repair: if the product has a minor defect
Destruction only becomes possible as a last resort, once all these options have been explored and documented.
Reporting obligations to meet
Above a certain volume placed on the French market, you must publish information about your unsold goods every year. Check the threshold that applies to your sector with your eco-organization.
The information to make public covers, among other things:
- The volume of products placed on the market
- The volume of unsold goods generated (stock and returns)
- The quantities reused, recycled, donated or destroyed
- The reasons for any destruction
Also check where and how this data must be published or submitted. Failing to meet these obligations exposes you to an administrative fine: find out the amount currently in force.
Damaged returns are not automatically destroyable
This is a common misconception. A product returned with opened or slightly damaged packaging is not eligible for destruction for that reason alone. The law is strict: you must first explore every alternative.
A garment that was tried on can be cleaned and resold through an outlet. An unboxed electronic device can be refurbished. A piece of furniture with a cosmetic defect can be donated. In principle, destruction is only allowed if the product poses a real health hazard or if no recovery channel exists.
In practice, this means you need fine-grained sorting of your returns, beyond a simple "resellable / not resellable".
How to document your practices
Traceability is your best protection in an inspection. You must be able to prove that you looked for alternatives before any destruction.
In practice, keep records of:
- Your agreements with charities for donations
- Your agreements with recyclers or refurbishers
- Refusals from these partners (some products do get turned down)
- The volumes handled by each channel
- Destruction decisions and their justification
These documents may be requested by the DGCCRF (France's consumer protection and fraud control authority) during an inspection. They also help you fill in your annual report if you are required to file one.
Recovery channels to identify now
Planning ahead is essential. You can't wait until you have hundreds of unsellable returns to look for solutions.
Start by identifying:
- Local charities that accept your types of products (Emmaüs, Croix-Rouge, Secours populaire…)
- Professional resale platforms for unboxed products
- Refurbishers specialized in your sector
- The eco-organizations for your sector (Refashion for textiles, ecosystem for electronics…)
Some of these partners offer regular pickups, others work on request. What matters is having these contacts in place before you need them.
Penalties for non-compliance
Enforcement falls notably to the DGCCRF. Penalties can be heavy:
- An administrative fine, set by current regulations
- An order to comply, possibly backed by daily penalty payments
- Possible publication of the sanction
Check the applicable penalties with an advisor. Beyond the legal side, this is also a reputational issue. Consumers are paying more and more attention to brands' environmental practices. The revelation of large-scale destruction of returns can damage your image for a long time.
What changes for your logistics
The AGEC law forces you to rethink your returns flow. The "anything that won't resell goes in the bin" model is no longer possible.
You need to plan for:
- A sorting area more detailed than a simple good or bad condition
- Cleaning or light refurbishing processes
- A buffer stock for products waiting for donation or recycling
- Tracking tools to document what happens to each return
This complexity has a cost, but it is now mandatory. Once the processes are in place, the extra cost can stay limited, and some channels (outlet, refurbished) can even generate additional revenue.
This article is general information: it does not replace legal advice tailored to your situation.
This article first appeared on the Hey’ Return blog, the returns management tool of the Heylio suite. Discover Hey’ Return