Key takeaways: Cross-border returns in Europe follow different VAT rules depending on whether the customer is in the EU, the United Kingdom or Switzerland. Controlling transit times and customs formalities has a direct effect on your cash flow and on your customers' satisfaction.
Returns from the EU: no customs, but variable transit times
When a European customer sends a product back to you, you stay within the single market. No customs formalities, but VAT follows precise rules: you refund the customer the price they paid, then the VAT is adjusted in your VAT return. The exact treatment depends on your scheme: check it with your accountant.
If you use the One Stop Shop (OSS), you declare the VAT on your EU distance sales from France. Otherwise, above a certain sales threshold, you may have to register for VAT in the countries concerned. Check the threshold and the rules in force with the tax authorities.
Return transit times vary widely from one country to another. They are often shorter from neighboring countries than from more distant ones, depending on logistics infrastructure and local carriers' practices. Measure them on your own returns rather than relying on an average.
The UK case: customs joins every return
Since Brexit, a return from the United Kingdom goes through customs. The parcel should normally carry a customs document (CN23 form or electronic declaration) stating the nature of the product, its value and the fact that it is a return.
For VAT, the treatment depends on the value of the shipment and on who collected the VAT at the time of sale. The UK applies its own rules and thresholds to small consignments: check with your freight forwarder or your accountant how to refund VAT in your case.
Transit times get longer as a matter of course, especially during busy customs periods. Some parcels stay stuck for several days at the border.
Switzerland and Norway: outside the EU, outside the comfort zone
Switzerland and Norway require customs formalities, even for returns. Each parcel must come with a commercial invoice and proof that it is a return.
For Switzerland, Swiss VAT applies on import. When an item is returned, how taxes are handled depends on the procedure in force: to avoid paying them twice, keep the original shipping records and the customs documents, and check the rate and procedure with your freight forwarder or the customs authorities.
Transit times are longer than for an intra-EU return, with a mandatory customs stop. Norway shows similar transit times, sometimes extended by additional checks on certain products (cosmetics, food).
Who pays for cross-border return shipping?
Who pays for the return depends on what you tell the customer before the purchase and on consumer law. Check the rules with an advisor before setting your policy. In practice, three models coexist.
You can offer a prepaid label for all returns, including cross-border ones. This approach makes things simple for the customer but weighs on your margins: a return from abroad costs much more than a domestic one.
You can also refund return shipping on proof of payment, up to a capped amount. This method shifts the complexity to the customer, who pays the shipping up front and then asks for a refund.
Finally, some brands offer free returns in France only and ask foreign customers to pay for their return. This practice is common, but it degrades the customer experience. State it clearly in your policy and check that it complies with the applicable rules.
Customs declaration pitfalls to avoid
An incomplete or inaccurate customs declaration can hold a parcel for days, even weeks. Three mistakes come up often.
The first: declaring a zero or token value to avoid duties. Such declarations risk being rejected or inspected. Always state the real value of the product, even for a return.
The second: forgetting to state that it is a return ("returned goods"). Without that wording, the parcel may be treated as a regular import, with duties to match.
The third: using approximate customs codes. Every product has an HS code (Harmonized System). A wrong code triggers extra checks. Build a list of codes for your most common products.
How to shorten your processing times
A return's total turnaround time breaks down into three phases: transporting the parcel, customs clearance if any, and your internal processing. You only truly control the last one.
For transport, favor carriers with an integrated European network over partnerships between national operators. Parcels change hands less often and transit times are more predictable.
For customs, plan ahead by giving the customer a pre-filled form with your EORI number and the product codes. You reduce declaration errors and speed up clearance.
For your internal processing, set yourself a short target, for example 48 hours after receipt. A customer who waits a long time for their parcel to arrive, then several more days for you to process it, has a poor experience, even if you meet the legal deadlines.
The impact on your cash flow
A cross-border return ties up cash longer than a domestic return. Between the customer shipping it and the refund, several weeks can easily go by.
Take an example: €100,000 in monthly international sales and a 15% return rate, so €15,000 of goods returned each month. If each return takes two weeks to come back, about half of that amount, €7,500, is permanently in transit. It generates no revenue, and you have often already refunded the customer.
Some brands refund when the returned parcel arrives, others as soon as the customer ships it (on proof of drop-off). The first option protects your cash flow, the second improves customer satisfaction. It's up to you to find the balance based on your financial situation and positioning.
Should you offer local return points?
Several European networks let customers drop off their return at a local pickup point, which then forwards it to France. This reduces costs for the customer and simplifies logistics.
The cost to you is often in the same range as a prepaid label. The advantage: you centralize flows and negotiate volume rates with a single provider.
The drawback: you add an intermediate step, and therefore delay. Weigh it against your sales volume per country: once orders become regular in a country, a local return point is worth considering.
This article is general information: it does not replace advice from an accountant, a freight forwarder or a legal advisor on your situation.
This article first appeared on the Hey’ Return blog, the returns management tool of the Heylio suite. Discover Hey’ Return